Goof of the Month: Gentle Driving Can Kill Your Turbo

Accelerometer With Turboc Lettering

Welcome to Stories of the Mechanically Declined! Every month, we highlight a story or situation that reinforces the need for drivers and shoppers to understand their vehicle, how to maintain it, how not to maintain it, and how it works.

This month’s story comes to us from automotive technician Nick Labrie, and highlights a somewhat common problem with the turbocharger system on a gently driven and well-used Volkswagen. This problem isn’t the result of a bad part, sensor, or user error; but in fact, a certain driving habit with potentially surprising consequences.

The Complaint

Labrie had a customer arrive with his Volkswagen Jetta, which had recently illuminated its Check Engine light, been running and idling poorly, getting bad mileage, and otherwise acting up.

Before arriving at Labrie’s shop, the owner had a neighbour perform a diagnostic scan on the vehicle, and that scan revealed a trouble code for an “Overboost” condition, which references an issue with the turbocharger.

“This was an older gentleman that we’d seen a few times before with this vehicle,” Labrie says. “He expected the worst, having convinced himself that the turbocharger was finished, and that it would require an expensive replacement. Thing is, the vehicle only had about 240,000 kilometres on it. We typically see these vehicles rack up plenty more miles than that before any serious issues with the engine, if at all.”

Labrie’s replaced a few turbochargers on Volkswagens like this one, but typically at much higher mileage.

Volkswagen Engine Bay

“I’ve seen a few turbochargers go bad at high miles on these machines, but for the most part, if you stay on top of maintenance and oil changes, they’ll last a very long time without issue.”

When the owner dropped the vehicle off to Labrie’s shop, he was quite concerned about the potential repair bill for the turbocharger. But, given the age of the vehicle, the problem described, and the initial diagnostic scan results, Labrie had a hunch.

“The customer was set to leave the car for a few days, assuming I’d have to order a new turbocharger and install it, but I told him and his wife to have a coffee in our waiting area for a half hour while I checked on something for him.”

Labrie believed that the problem lay with the turbocharger’s wastegate, and not the turbocharger itself.

The turbocharger is an air compressor driven by an engine’s exhaust gasses. Exhaust gas exiting the engine is hot, expanding and full of energy. By routing it through a turbine, the energy in the exhaust gas is used to drive, or spin, the turbocharger. Effectively, a turbocharger sits in the engine’s exhaust stream, borrowing some of the energy from the exhaust as it exits the engine. In this picture, exhaust is forced through the turbine visible at the bottom of the turbocharger, causing it to spin rapidly, and driving the turbocharger into action. After driving the turbine, the exhaust gasses are routed through the exhaust system and out of the tailpipe.

The wastegate is a mechanical component used to control turbocharger boost pressure. When needed, boost pressure from the turbocharger is applied to a diaphragm, which operates a metal rod, which in turn opens a small trapdoor inside of the turbocharger. When that trapdoor is opened, a controlled amount of exhaust gas is bled off and allowed to leak past the turbocharger, thereby keeping the boost from exceeding a certain limit. Here’s a video on how a turbocharger wastegate works.

“Sometimes, the metal rod and assembly that opens the wastegate seizes up when it gets old. When that happens, the turbocharger can’t control its boost level, meaning the boost goes too high, and a Check Engine light comes on, and the engine goes into limp mode. This causes the sort of problems the customer was experiencing. It’s a way for the engine to protect itself until the problem is sorted.”

The Outcome

Toyota MR2 Engine Bay
Labrie first performed a diagnostic test, confirming the presence of a sole trouble code for Overboost, thereby replicating the results the owner obtained from an earlier scan by his neighbour. He then moved to the wastegate assembly for a closer look.

“Not knowing any better, the owner thought the trouble code meant his turbocharger was pooched,” Labrie says. “In fact, the turbocharger was fine, but the wastegate rod, and the hinge that it rides on, were both fairly badly seized and rusty. I hit the system with the vacuum gun, applying the amount of pressure required to open the wastegate – but the metal rod didn’t move.”

Translation? When the engine tried to regulate the turbocharger boost pressure, the mechanical side of the system failed because of the seized wastegate assembly, meaning that boost pressure climbed too high, and that limp mode was engaged.

So, the vehicle didn’t need a new turbocharger, it just needed some attention to its wastegate, which is a less expensive repair. But Labrie, trying to save his customer some cash, had an even cheaper solution.

“I pulled apart the accessible parts of the wastegate assembly, removing the rod and hinge. Then, I dismantled those, cleaned the rust off with a wire-wheel to smooth the surfaces, lubricated them generously, and put them back together.”

Labrie’s repair freed up the seized wastegate assembly – and a second check with the vacuum gun confirmed that with cleaning and lubrication, the assembly was now operating properly. This wasn’t a permanent fix – but it would allow the owner to drive without issue, for a while.

“I told the owner that his car was fine now – and he was thrilled. It only took about an hour. I explained that, usually, you need to replace the wastegate, and that if the problem came back, that’s what we’d likely have to do. But for now, he’d get, probably, another year or so out of it. I gave him a quote to replace the wastegate if and when the time came, and he was on his way.”

Using a turbocharger or supercharger to ‘boost’ an engine's power, thereby making a smaller engine perform like a larger one, is one of the oldest go-fast tricks in the book. It’s even more relevant nowadays, as fuel savings are realized by offsetting some of the engine’s output to a turbocharger or supercharger, rather than simply using a bigger, thirstier engine. Using boost generates the on-demand power drivers want, with reduced fuel consumption when they’re driving gently. In a nutshell, using a smaller, boosted engine instead of a larger one means drivers will burn less fuel, more of the time, with no compromise in performance.

Lesson Learned

The reason the wastegate failed, according to Labrie, is an interesting one, caused by the owner’s driving habits. “We had a little chat about the owner’s driving, and I asked him how often he opens the engine up.”

According to Labrie, the wastegate assembly moves fully only when drivers apply fairly heavy throttle, though this owner admitted to driving the car gently at almost all times, and never giving it much pedal.

“Because this customer and his wife are both light-footed drivers, the engine rarely works very hard, and the turbocharger rarely works very hard, which means the wastegate rod rarely moves fully, if at all. This is a part that’s designed to move, and over time, if it doesn’t, it gets rusty and seized,” Labrie comments.

“I told the customer, every once in a while, to give the car some heavy gas – which will get the turbo and wastegate working, and hopefully, help keep things from seizing. It’s one of those things where, occasionally, a good full-throttle blast can be helpful. Just like people, some car parts get stiff and seized if they don’t move for a long time.”

All said, as Labrie’s latest customer learned, in some situations, a bit of full-throttle acceleration might save you a trip to the shop.

The following two tabs change content below.
Justin Pritchard
Justin Pritchard is a native of Windsor, Ontario – though he’s called Sudbury his home for the past 20 years. Justin is a full-time auto writer, consultant and presenter of EastLink TV’s AutoPilot. His work can be seen weekly in numerous outlets across the country. When not writing about the latest new models and industry trends, you’ll probably find him fixing his 1993 Toyota MR2 GTS.
Justin Pritchard

Latest posts by Justin Pritchard (see all)

  • Daniel Libich

    After the customer was concerned of a hefty bill to replace the entire turbo on their TDI jetta before a neighbor who had access to a scan tool revealed a code for “over boost” when all the issue was a seized up waste gate before the technician had a chat with the customer when they were lightly driving the car when periodically they would use medium to heavy throttle to get the turbo and its components working properly.

  • Jonathon Eaton

    LMFAO, using vacuum to check operating rod of wastgate for movement. The wastegate references pressure, so it would be compressed air you hit it with to get the rod to actuate…

  • David Ure

    I am opening up the Golf R ever chance I get tomorrow. Thanks Justin (where do I send my speeding tickets?)

  • James Preston

    That would otherwise only work if you have access to the inside of the wastegate. Applying vacuum to the outside would activate it as well

  • Guylain Ouellette

    Beeing a vw diesel owner for the last 20 years, this is my motto “WOT (wide open throttle) once a day keeps the garage bay away”
    Don’t be affraid to beat your diesel!!

    I’ve cleaned more then my share of wastegate assemblies.

  • lilmikey_ab

    Longest sentence ever.. makes no sense without punctuation…

  • Goldmarble

    The wastegate works over a pressure differential. So long as one side is higher pressure than the other, the device will work properly. So, when he applies vacuum to the outlet, the inlet is experiencing up to 14.7 psi of regular, atmospheric pressure.

  • Alpine917

    Did they correctly diagnose the fault and perform an economical repair? the only letter that comes to mind on your comment is “A”.

  • Nadim

    I thought it was just a mazda rx-8 problem … good thing I don’t drive a turbo. I do regularly pin it on on-ramps, away from stop signs and merging traffic … but I like to keep it under 4 k rpm

  • Login_to_logout

    An RX-8 isn’t turbo. So no wastegate.

  • Chris Lortie

    You’re correct in that rotary engines need to be revved out frequently, but the buildup is just carbon. Carbon dioxide is a gas.

  • Sam BK

    Not that it matters but, That picture is of a Passat, not a Jetta…

  • camaro_mang

    so you have to go fast to prevent problems eh, fascinating